The Problem With Facebook Writers’ Groups

Facebook writer’s groups sound great.  There’s a reason they’re a dime a dozen, after all.  In theory, they’re a great place to share thoughts on story structure, ask grammar questions, or pick up tips about marketing and publicity.

They sound great.

Unfortunately, far too many are absolutely useless.

While a handful are great–I’m part of at least one that is made up of a fairly close-knit group of writers that falls into that category–most are absolute crap in my opinion.

Why?

It’s simple.  Far too many of those groups aren’t really about writing.  Instead, they’ve morphed into authors promoting their books to other authors.  The idea is that indies should support each other, and I can kind of get that, but only to a point.

If there are 100,000 indie authors on Amazon, you may be thinking that’s plenty of potential customers, but think a bit about those authors.  How many are into regency romance, but not heroic fantasy?  Every reader tends to have genres they prefer.  This is also true of writers.  For example, I’m not particularly intrigued by romances, though I do plan on reading some written by a particular friend, but that’s because I know how his (yes, his) mind works and I know it won’t be the typical bodice ripper.

My point, however, is that writers have preferred genres and that means unless you write a genre they like, they won’t buy your book.  It’s OK though, because you aren’t likely to buy theirs either, and for the same reason.

That now drops you down to the few thousand in your genre.  Do you really want to live off of that?

Not only that but how many of those writers are actually looking for stuff to read?

Many authors have “To Be Read” piles big enough to qualify as one of the Wonders of the World.  Others don’t read much fiction anymore because they are reading stuff for research on their novels.  They’re not necessarily looking for your book.

Even those like myself who do still read a lot of fiction and don’t have tremendous piles waiting to read aren’t good candidates for your marketing efforts.  After all, most writers are holding down 9-5 jobs, which means their reading time and writing time occupy the same space.  What do you think most writers are going to do?

That’s not to say you’ll never sell a book in one of these groups.  Sure you will.  A few of them, actually.  In fact, it’s just enough that some will think this is a workable strategy.

It’s not.

What it does is turn many of these supposed writer’s groups into annoying Hellmouth’s of Facebook, with nothing but promotion and no actual discussion of the craft of writing taking place.

Yes, you can still post a question, but will anyone see it beneath the avalanche of promotion these groups become?  No.  I’ve found remarkably few people actually pay any attention to much in the group.

If you’re happy netting a couple dozen sales that way, then more power to you.  Personally, I’m hunting bigger game.

 

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The Problem With Facebook Writers’ Groups”

  1. I’ve taken myself out of several groups for this very reason. They were too much of a time suck and I wasn’t getting anything out of them except a bunch of annoying memes.

    Like

    1. Precisely.

      There are some good groups out there, but I find that if there’s no rule against promotion, even if it’s just limiting it to once a week or something, it soon becomes everything and the group becomes useless.

      Like

      1. I have chosen to steer well away from any writers’ groups myself. There just are too many out there that are pointless to be in and I feel that my time is better spent working on my craft.

        Like

        1. I don’t blame you.

          The one I’m in is geared more toward quick questions and input from other writers, almost all of whom have published, rather than sitting around and critiquing each other’s work.

          Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s